Which is better judo or jujitsu

Because Samurai wore armor, jujutsu focused on throwing gouges, throws, and locks, which worked against an armored opponent. In , the Meiji Restoration ended the feudal system, and Samurai became extinct. People were no longer allowed to wear swords in public, and martial art schools started to collapse.

That is when a young man named Jigoro Kano became captivated with this form of art and wanted to spread it. He knew that he would have to tweak jujutsu for mass acceptance, especially for the latest political landscape.

Kano opted for a scientific approach and strived for maximum efficiency in human movement, which gave birth to Judo. In , he was invited as the first Asian representative from Japan to the Olympic Committee.

In , Judo became an Olympic sport at the Tokyo games. Even though Kano traveled the whole world, it was a judoka named Mitsuyo Maeda who brought Judo to Brazil. He traveled all over South and North America.

Maeda arrived in Brazil in and started an academy there. He met with Gastao Gracie, introducing his son Carlos Gracie to it. Soon enough, Carlos started to train along with his brothers, Jorge, Helio, and Oswaldo. These fights pitted styles against one another in no holds barred matches. Even though it started from Kodokan Judo, over the past decade, it has morphed into a form of martial art that spends a majority of the time on the ground.

The main reason why Judo and BJJ seem to be the same is that they have common ancestors; sprouting from the same root, both of them are intertwined with one another. The difference between the two can be understood by looking at the following factors:.

Judo and BJJ share many similar techniques, such as joint locks, chokeholds, and throws. The main difference in techniques is how they are executed and the stress that each art places on the body.

Judo focuses more on the throwing techniques, whereas BJJ focuses more on submission and groundwork, which makes a lot of difference. Judo provides you with a firm grip on your opponent, flooring them with a trip or a throw and throwing them off balance. The person who shows better control and grip ends up winning.

One thing to keep in mind is that ground fighting is not a main priority in Judo. If the round ends up on the ground, you get 30 seconds maximum to submit or pin your opponent before you restart it and stand back up. Meanwhile, the BJJ strategy is focused more on the ground. In fact, most BJJ schools let you start on the ground, but you need to keep in mind that tournaments start while standing, so you cannot avoid the standup game either.

Your main goal in BJJ is to learn how to dominate your opponent by controlling their movement. The ruleset for each art also differentiates between the two. This is another hard question to answer because there is little data to analyze. However, we estimated the calorie burn during a BJJ session based on some existing research. Based on this data, and compared to data in fitness trackers like My Fitness Pal , it appears that a BJJ session with the same amount of sparring time will burn a bit more calories than judo.

Limited research showed BJJ sparring burns calories per 30 minute session, versus calories per 30 minute judo session. It should be noted that these numbers are highly dependent on personal attributes, school style, training partners, and so on. In the end, both exercises are fantastic calorie burners.

There have been some fights throughout history pitting judo against BJJ. The results are mixed — with BJJ fighters winning some of the time, judo fighters winning other times, and a few fights declared no-contest or draw. It is hard to to declare a superior art from these results, with the outcome seemingly more dependent on the conditions of the fighters themselves. This was a no-gi event with no points awarded, so the environment was certainly slanted in favor of BJJ.

The BJJ team defeated the judo team, but it was a narrow victory with a few of the fights ending in draws. Ultimately, with both arts being close in many aspects, it might come down to personal preference. Try both of them out, and see which art suits you better.

Both are difficult to learn. If we are talking about the basics, judo is probably more difficult. It takes time to develop the essential timing and footwork for proficiency. For depth of sport, BJJ has more depth to explore and that takes longer to learn once basics are understood. Because there is much more volume of throws, judo can be harder on a body. Simply getting thrown over and over — even on good mats — takes a toll. This is a generalization here, but judo is more likely to incorporate traditional martial art values than BJJ but this is obviously not always the case.

For this reason, and because it is much more established with curriculums and testing, I would recommend judo slightly over BJJ for children. In the end, both arts are wonderful activities and neither should be easily dismissed. Through their common ancestry, both judo and BJJ have much in common.

It is valuable to understand the differences between the two arts, especially to take advantage of cross training opportunities. It is highly recommended that you try both of them out and form your own opinion, and benefit from both fantastic martial arts in the process. What are your thoughts on judo versus BJJ? Have you had any experience cross training in either sport? Comment below! He has been training for 5 years in BJJ and has previous experience in other various martial arts.

Besides BJJ, he enjoys reading, writing, and other sports. Thats a good article. The observations I came away with were — yes there was almost no tachi-waza standup ability with the BJJ practitioners. In pride competitions BJJ fighters are routinely beaten. The reason being that Judo in the West is not quite like Judo in Japan. Judo in Japan is a school sport so the levels of proficiency are very high. Just watch any of the multitude of Youtube videos of them speaking. They lie, they rig rules and at least in Japan are often beaten.

In Brazil this did not happen perhaps due to the timing and language barrier. With regard to Maeda — his story is much more complex. Before the Kodokan was really just a small relatively unestablished school. It progressed quickly after that. Maeda — like Kano had originally trained in some of the other Jujutsu strains.

They are all inter-related and Kano realizing this attempted a little later to absorb all of them via his Kobudo training in the Kodokan. But Kano sent him out into the world to promote the Kodokan after training in more formalized Kodokan techniques, however Maeda was also previously trained as mentioned.

As a result Tani went around the UK offering challenge matches i. They ran the school of Jujutsu in London before its remnants later became the Budokwai it was to become the European Kodokan before Kano died and finished that negotiation.

Maeda had become friends Gunji Koizumi with Tano and was later ordered to travel to south america where he gave similar catch-can wrestling matches. Not all joined the Kodokan however such as Fusen Ryu practitioners and Newaza experts Koizumi and Tanabe the eventual Grandmaster — equal to Kano who had regularly beaten Kodokan members in Newaza.

Tanabe was then invited of course to the Kodokan and his techniques helped solidify Kosen Judo. One should never underestimate Tachi-waza, the throwing portion of jujutsu.

A throw on concrete will kill or mame an opponent. For example the counter to the BJJ guard and choke is a pressure point strike to the genitals or eyes as one still has their hands free.

In a no-holds barred fight I think a BJJ fighter cannot fundamentally win because the concentration on Newaza is too narrow. So in the end BJJ relies on soft matts i. Then Kimura broke his arm in what has become known since as the Kimura lock. So in the end We come back to Bruce Lee who looked at all of this and decided to change wing chun fist to include western boxing, locks and low kicks in what he called the art of nothing i. He did not waste his time in UFC etc because of the rules.

We are yet to see real head to head matches except in south east asia where you really see nasty results deaths and the like when the rules are removed and Muai Thai and Shoalin boxers etc can go at it un-inhibited by rules.

Most martial artists including bjj practitioners are not used to having their head smashed in. So take all of this stuff with a grain of salt — all these arts have rules that inhibit success. As a Kodokan practitioner I can only use a fraction of Judo in Olympic IJF matches but thats not to say the techniques are not there to be used to kill the oponent.

The main problem with BJJ is that because it is Judo, albeit Newaza — the other techniques are not taught and the traditions and etiquette are not taught generally. But one cannot deny that on the ground they are going for broke.

Wow what a great response — thanks for taking the time to read and write such a detailed reply Greg. Lots of very interesting information here! I totally concur with Greg, spot on, but on the article about self defence I would have to disagree, because you compared the rules in IJF judo to the street, and the street is where self defence usually occurs. I do both but Judo definately has BJJ over self defence because of the throws.

Morote Hari, teguruma, kanibasami etc. The other two fighters were Yamaguchi sixth-degree black belt and Yukio Kato fifth-degree black belt. The Japanese were reportedly afraid that if Gracie lost to Kimura, he would simply blame their weight differential.

On Sept. Kato reportedly dominated the early goings, with Gracie taking the later stages of the fight. Kato then challenged Gracie to a rematch, which took place 23 days later at Pacaembu Gymnasium. Early on, the Japanese fighter threw Gracie hard.

He also tried a choke with which Gracie had trouble. Before long, Gracie regained his strength and won the match, leaving Kato fell unconscious. On Oct. Just about a month earlier, Gracie had defeated one of the best judo fighters in the world, Yukio Kato, by choke. Hence, there was a lot of pressure on Kimura, who had a to pound weight advantage on his smaller adversary.

Kimura was widely considered to be the greatest judo fighter in the world, so the Japanese people were counting on him. Coming into the match, Kimura indicated that he would knock his opponent out with a throw and that if Gracie were to last more than three minutes, he'd consider himself the winner.

Kimura dominated the match from a throwing perspective, continually slamming Gracie into what was apparently a somewhat soft mat. Since these moves did not stop Gracie as he thought they might, Kimura then began looking for submissions. After roughly 12 minutes, Gracie had been rendered unconscious by a choke but somehow persevered. Kimura sunk in a reverse ude-garami shoulder lock , but Gracie was so tough that he refused to submit, having his arm broken instead.

Eventually, his corner threw in the towel, and Kimura was rightfully given the win. Judo won out here. But in the process, Gracie and Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu certainly gained some respect. Here's how Kimura described the event:. Sure, Pardoel had a jiu-jitsu background as well; but who in judo didn't at the time?

It took Gracie some time to get Pardoel to the ground, as the big man outweighed him by 84 pounds. Once he did, Pardoel went for a kimura and missed. Gracie then used his gi to sink in the lapel choke, winning after only minutes in round one. During the match, Gracie quickly found himself on his back, with Yoshida on top. The two eventually came to their feet and went back to the ground, where Yoshida sunk in a gi-choke which resulted in the match being stopped.

Gracie immediately contested the loss, indicating that he could've fought on and was completely conscious when the referee chose to stop the bout. PRIDE accepted their demands. On Dec. Interestingly, Gracie entered the fight without a gi on and would've clearly won the match by decision, had the rules allowed judges to get involved. Instead, after two minute rounds did not result in a stoppage, the bout was declared a draw.

This wasn't a true Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu vs.